Below is a breakdown of the 2009 NCHA Futurity finalists’ sires. Dual Rey was the leading sire in all divisions and in terms of total offspring earnings – $833,902. His foals earned $576,862 in the Open Finals; $136,326 in the Non-Pro Finals; and $30,121 in the Amateur. High Brow Cat offspring earned a total of $711,256, while Smooth As A Cat ranked third in total offspring earnings with $535,650. In all, the offspring of 75 different stallions earned checks at the show. (Total earnings reflect all divisions, including limited, semi-finals and senior.)
| Sires (11) of Open Finalists (28) | |
| Dual Rey | 7 |
| High Brow Cat | 6 |
| Smooth As A Cat | 5 |
| Pepto Boonsmal | 3 |
| Abracadabracre | 1 |
| Cats Merada | 1 |
| Mecom Blue | 1 |
| Mr Peppys Freckles | 1 |
| Peeka Pep | 1 |
| Spots Hot | 1 |
| That Sly Cat | 1 |
| Sires (18) of Non-Pro Finalists (26) | |
| Dual Rey | 4 |
| High Brow Cat | 3 |
| Peptoboonsmal | 2 |
| Playgun | 2 |
| Smooth As A Cat | 2 |
| Bobs Freckle | 1 |
| Boonlight Dancer | 1 |
| Boonsmal Cee Lena | 1 |
| Chula Dual | 1 |
| Dualin Boon | 1 |
| Hes A Petospoonful | 1 |
| Pepto Taz | 1 |
| Reys Dual Badger | 1 |
| Smart Lil Scoot | 1 |
| Smart Little Lena | 1 |
| Sweet Lil Pepto | 1 |
| Wise Play | 1 |
| Zack T Wood | 1 |
| Sires (22) of Amateur Finalists (33) | |
| Dual Rey | 4 |
| Cat Ichi | 3 |
| Dual Pep | 3 |
| High Brow Cat | 2 |
| Playgun | 2 |
| Smart Little Lena | 2 |
| Abilene Acre | 1 |
| Cats Red Feather | 1 |
| Chula Dual | 1 |
| Docs Christmas | 1 |
| Downtown Cat | 1 |
| Dualin Boon | 1 |
| Hes A Peptospoonful | 1 |
| Kit Dual | 1 |
| Peeka Pep | 1 |
| Peptos Stylish Oak | 1 |
| Peptotime | 1 |
| Playdox | 1 |
| Playin Stylish | 1 |
| Smart Mate | 1 |
| Son Of Oak | 1 |
| Travalena | 1 |